Find your perfect whodunnit in our guide to murder mystery games, from board games like Mysterium to subscriptions like Hunt a Killer

Murder mystery games have come a long way since the days of Cluedo. Those clever people designing tabletop games have found ways to add even more suspects, red herrings, and paper handouts to modern murder mystery board games, so there’s more reason than ever to don your detective’s deerstalker and go looking for clues. But there’s one mystery you’ll need to solve first – which is the right murder mystery game for you?

The fact murder mystery games are better than ever also means there’s more choice than ever. Do you want a hardcore puzzler your party solves together, or do you prefer a game where the suspect hides among you, and no one can be trusted? Do you want to close the case in a single evening, or are you after a mystery that’ll keep you awake for weeks on end?

Whatever kind of murder mystery games you’re into, this guide will have a suggestion for you. We’ve got the nose for crime-themed tabletop games, so our recommendations will seem elementary.

These are the best murder mystery games:

Hunt a Killer is the premium option if you’re looking for a murder mystery game that lasts more than a few hours. Each individual box takes between 90 minutes and three hours to complete, but Hunt a Killer offers mysteries that take place over multiple ‘episode’ boxes.

You can keep up with the most recent mysteries by opting for a subscription that delivers episodes incrementally, or you can get a full mystery series in one go by purchasing a box set. Of course, if you prefer a one-and-done mystery game, there are also premium boxes to fill this need.

The downside of all these premium options is they also come with a premium price tag. A quarterly subscription costs $99 / £81.99 a month, while box sets can cost up to $149 / £123.40 . A single premium box can cost anywhere between $32 / £26.50 and $228 / £188.95. Considering each mystery is only playable once, this might be too steep an asking price for some.

Still, Hunt a Killer offers a wide variety of mysteries, ranging from gritty true crime to doughnut-themed mystery jigsaws. The boxes are ideal for a maximum of six players, and it’s recommended players be over the age of 13 (murders do tend to involve upsetting details, after all). If you’re a hardcore crime-solver, the huge amount of content available from Hunt a Killer might just be worth the price of entry.

Mysterium isn’t your traditional murder mystery board game. It asks you to crack codes and find a killer, but you do so by interpreting images given to you by the ghost of the murdered party.

One player takes on the role of this ghost. The ghost cannot speak – they can only give clues to their killer by revealing cards showing abstract pictures. After that, they’ve got to hope the living players can connect their image to the right murderer, murder location, and murder weapon. These detectives are contacting the ghost by supernatural means, and they only have a limited time to make their guesses in.

This is a cooperative game for up to seven players, but there is a scoring system that determines who the ultimate psychic detective is. Mysterium doesn’t offer a narrative or puzzles to solve, but it does have something more conventional murder mystery games don’t – it’s got endless replay value. It’s also one of our favourite board games for adults.

We’ve recommended One Night Ultimate Werewolf to tabletop gamers for all sorts of reasons. It’s one of our top funny board games, and it’s one of the games like Among Us that might convert digital gamers to the physical gaming space. Honestly, we consider it one of the best board games around these days – and it happens to be a great take on the bluffing/murder mystery genre.

In One Night Ultimate Werewolf, the killer is at least one of the players. The game begins by assigning everyone a secret role, and one or more of your group will discover they are a werewolf. Gameplay forces everyone to close their eyes and ‘go to sleep’ – and this is when the werewolves strike, killing a hapless snoozer.

Fortunately, some of the villagers get to perform actions during the night too. You might be a seer who can check other players’ roles, or you could be a troublemaker who swaps the roles of others around. Whatever you become, the humans must discover the identity of the werewolves, and hang one the next morning. Werewolves and their minions win if an innocent player gets lynched.

One Night Ultimate Werewolf is a gallows humour bluffing game filled with finger-pointing and fantastic fun. It can be played by three to ten players in under ten minutes (there are longer versions of the same game, but this is the superior version, in our humble opinion).

The Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective has everything a mystery fan could want – intriguing stories, papers to analyse, and puzzles to solve. Oh yes, and Sherlock Holmes himself.

Holmes does make an appearance in the series, but he won’t be helping you catch the criminals. Instead, your team must figure the mystery out yourselves – and then you’ll be graded on how close you were to beating Holmes to the same conclusion.

This is perhaps the game’s weakest point. Holmes is nearly impossible to beat, sometimes finding the culprit in just three turns. Your final score suffers if you can’t match these big-brain plays, which feels a little punishing for thorough detectives who like to explore every avenue before making an accusation.

Luckily, this scoring system is easily ignored – the mysteries are compelling enough that getting the correct answers is reward enough. And while the stories aren’t replayable, there are multiple in a single box, and the series now has several different expansions to keep you guessing.

Blood on the Clocktower has the same core concept as One Night Ultimate Werewolf: a randomly chosen player kills other players at night, and they win if they can eliminate the majority of ‘good’ players without being detected and executed. This game takes place over several nights, however, and it introduces extra mechanics that add the complexity and intrigue the Werewolf series sometimes lacks.

Blood on the Clocktower can support up to 20 players, so it’s ideal for anyone with lots of murder mystery fans to cater for. There aren’t many opportunities to figure out puzzles in this game, but it’s got plenty of bluffing – and perhaps a little roleplaying, if your group is enthusiastic enough.

There are some downsides, though. Firstly, this is another premium price game – you can expect to pay $145 for a copy. Secondly, it’s currently tricky to get a hold of a physical copy. Delays to the original Kickstarter and a lack of stock mean buying Blood on the Clocktower can be a bit of a mystery in itself.

Every bit of DnD and MTG news revealed at Wizards Presents

Doctor Who travels to Universes Beyond in new MTG cards

You (yes, you) can playtest the next DnD edition right now

MTG Dominaria United has Sagas, and some really disturbing art

A wild Pokémon Ultra-Premium Charizard box appears online

GW reveals new 40k, AoS minis to lure fans to Warhammer Plus

Mollie's DnD characters often seem more at home in her favourite board game, Betrayal at House on the Hill. Spook and storyteller, she loves poetry as much as a good TTRPG. (She/her)